Why you should be careful when filling up gas in unfamiliar gas stations

Justin S
Oct 22, 2025

Have you ever stopped at a gas station you weren't familiar with? It might seem harmless enough, but filling up at an unfamiliar gas station can pose some risks. Whether you're traveling through a new area or just need a quick fill-up, being cautious can help you avoid some potentially serious issues. Let's start by outlining the reasons why you should always be careful when filling up at gas stations you don't know.

1. Fuel Quality

First, you should keep in mind that not all gas stations abide by the same fuel quality standards. Smaller low-cost gas stations might not have the same standards as well-known chains. Sometimes, they might use lower-quality fuel, which can affect your car's performance. There's also the risk of fuel tampering. Some unscrupulous gas station owners may try to boost profits by adding things to the fuel that could damage your engine. By filling up at a new unknown gas station, you might not know if the fuel meets the same standards as major brands.

2. Fuel Pump Equipment

At unfamiliar stations, the fuel pumps might be older or not as well-maintained. This could lead to inadvertent fuel contamination, spills and safety issues. Additionally, it is not uncommon for older pumps with poor maintenance history to dispense the incorrect fuel, which means you might end up paying for more fuel than you need or getting the wrong type of fuel octane.

3. Customer Support

You are more likely to encounter staff that might not be as knowledgeable or attentive in smaller budget gas stations. If you have questions or encounter a technical issue with the pump, you might not get the right support.

4. Security

Security is another big issue. Unfamiliar gas stations, especially in less-traveled areas, might have higher risks of theft or robbery. If you're filling up at night, it's especially important to be cautious. Also, there's the risk of someone tampering with your fuel cap or car after you fill up. Some stations might have fever security measures, making you a target. It's better to stick to well-known chains, when possible, especially if you're in an unfamiliar area.

5. Scams

Scams and overcharging are also valid concerns. Some unfamiliar stations might try to upsell you on services you don't need, like car washes or oil changes, even if you don't want them. They might also have higher prices than you'd expect. Sometimes, they might use confusing discount pricing structures. It's good to compare prices with nearby stations or use your phone to check if the price seems reasonable before filling up.

Being careful when filling up at unfamiliar gas stations is smart. It helps protect your car from potential damage, keeps you safe, and saves you from possible scams. If you need to fill up in an unfamiliar area, try to stick to well-known gas station chains with good reputations. If you must use a smaller station, do a quick check of the area, make sure the station looks well-maintained, and be aware of your surroundings. Your car and your wallet will thank you for being cautious.